Butter Chicken Cheesesteak
The Butter Chicken Cheesesteak combines tender marinated chicken with a creamy, spiced butter chicken sauce served on a cheesesteak roll, blending Indian and American sandwich traditions into one dish.
Recommended
Garden Pizza & Grill
- Location
- Philadelphia
What the creator ordered
- Butter Chicken Cheesesteak
- The Boat (pizza boat with crispy chicken and marinara)
Standout moments
- +The intense flavor of the butter chicken cheesesteak.
- +The butter chicken sauce soaking into the roll.
- +The unique 'Boat' sandwich, described as a giant, crispy, and soft bagel bite.
- +The spicy marinara sauce on 'The Boat'.
Creator tips
- The owner cooks the butter chicken sauce separately from the chicken to ensure an intense flavor from both components.
Was this review helpful?
Tips & Notes
Pro tips
- Marinate the chicken for at least 2-4 hours to ensure the spices penetrate and tenderize the meat.
- Toast the cheesesteak roll lightly before assembly to prevent it from becoming soggy from the sauce.
- Melt the cheese over warm chicken so it adheres fully, then top with the butter chicken sauce for maximum flavor integration.
- Serve immediately after assembly while the roll is warm and the cheese is still melted.
Substitutions
- Cheesesteak roll → ciabatta or hoagie roll (changes texture slightly but maintains structure)
- Provolone → mozzarella or American cheese (adjusts flavor profile but melts similarly)
Storage & make-ahead
Store leftover butter chicken sauce in an airtight container for up to 3 days; marinated chicken keeps 2-3 days. Reheat sauce gently and cook chicken fresh for best results; assembled sandwiches are best eaten immediately.
Common Questions
What makes this cheesesteak different from a traditional one?
Instead of steak, this uses marinated chicken and features a rich butter chicken sauce with aromatic spices, creating an Indian-American fusion sandwich.
Can I make the butter chicken sauce ahead of time?
Yes, the butter chicken sauce can be prepared in advance and refrigerated, then reheated gently before assembling the sandwich.
Is this sandwich spicy?
The butter chicken sauce has warm spices and can range from mild to medium heat depending on the amount of chili used in the marinade and sauce.
What type of cheese works best?
Provolone or American cheese are traditional cheesesteak choices, but mozzarella also melts well and complements the butter chicken sauce.
