Best Sandwiches in Key West
A curated guide to the best sandwich destinations in Key West, Florida, covering authentic Cuban sandwiches, fresh lobster rolls, and local breakfast bagel spots recommended by food guide @theshayspence.
Recommended
Goldman's Deli
- Location
- Key West, FL
What the creator ordered
- Pastrami Egg and Cheese Bagel from Goldman's Deli
- Italian Hoagie from Mr. Z's
- Cuban Sandwich from Ana's Cuban Cafe
- Fish Sandwich from B.O.'s Fish Wagon
- Grilled Garlic Shrimp Roll from DJ's Clam Shack
- Key Lime Butter Lobster Roll from Key West Lobster Shack
- Fried Chicken Sandwich from Tin Cup Chalice Bar
- Sazon Chicken Sandwich from White Tarpon
- Mojo Marinated Steak Sandwich from Frita's Cuban Burger Cafe
- Key West Club Sandwich from Moondog Cafe
Standout moments
Was this review helpful?
Tips & Notes
Pro tips
- Cuban sandwiches are traditionally pressed on a plancha or griddle until the bread is crispy and the cheese melts; the key is using authentic Cuban bread
- Fresh lobster rolls are best served cold with minimal mayo; order from spots that source local Key West lobster for the freshest flavor
- Breakfast bagels in Key West often feature local ingredients like fresh seafood and tropical flavors alongside traditional breakfast meats and cheeses
Equipment
video player (recipe includes video guide)
Common Questions
What is the most iconic sandwich in Key West?
Cuban sandwiches are considered Key West's most iconic sandwich, featuring ham, roast pork, Swiss cheese, pickles, and mustard on Cuban bread, pressed and grilled.
Where should I go for the best lobster roll in Key West?
This guide covers the top local spots for fresh lobster rolls. Check the video and recommendations for specific restaurant names and locations.
Are there good breakfast sandwich options in Key West?
Yes, the guide includes several local spots known for breakfast bagels and morning sandwich specialties throughout Key West.
Is this guide based on personal experience?
Yes, @theshayspence shares his personal favorites and recommendations from visiting these local Key West sandwich establishments.
