American Beauty Cocktail

Pro tips

• Use fresh-squeezed orange juice rather than bottled for brighter, cleaner flavor that doesn't overpower the vermouth and gin.
• Add the crème de menthe as a true dash (small pour) — it's easy to overdo and will make the drink cloying.
• Shake vigorously with ice for 10-15 seconds to properly dilute and chill; strain immediately to avoid over-watering.

Substitutions

• Dry vermouth (Italian) → French vermouth (lighter, more delicate note)
• Orange juice → grapefruit juice (more bitter, less sweet balance)
• Old Mr. Boston Dry Gin → another London Dry gin (slight botanical variation, same category)

Storage & make-ahead

Mix cocktails to order; do not store mixed drinks. Store opened vermouth and gin in cool, dark conditions; use within 1 year of opening.

Equipment

cocktail shaker · jigger or measuring cup · fine mesh strainer

What type of gin works best for an American Beauty Cocktail?

Use a London Dry style gin with prominent juniper and botanical notes to stand up to the vermouth and citrus without being overpowered.

Can I make American Beauty Cocktails in advance?

Mix individual servings fresh to preserve the citrus brightness and prevent separation. Pre-batch the vermouth and gin, then add juice and grenadine when serving.

Should this cocktail be shaken or stirred?

Shake with ice to properly chill and integrate the orange juice and grenadine, then strain into a glass.

What does the crème de menthe add to this drink?

The crème de menthe (one dash) adds subtle mint complexity and slight sweetness that rounds out the citrus and botanical flavors.