Brandy Toddy

Pro tips

• Dissolve powdered sugar completely in hot water before adding brandy to ensure even sweetness.
• Warm your glass first by rinsing it with hot water to keep the drink at the right temperature longer.
• Do not boil the brandy; pour hot water into the glass first, then add brandy to preserve its flavor.

Substitutions

• Powdered sugar → granulated sugar or honey (stir well to dissolve)
• Old Mr. Boston Five Star Brandy → cognac or other brandy (adjust quantity to taste)

Storage & make-ahead

Serve immediately while warm; Brandy Toddies do not store well.

What type of brandy should I use for a Brandy Toddy?

Use a quality brandy like Old Mr. Boston Five Star or similar; avoid aged or premium varieties that would be wasted on a heated drink.

Should the water be boiling hot?

Yes, use hot water just below boiling to warm the glass and blend the sugar without damaging the brandy's flavor.

Can I make a Brandy Toddy without powdered sugar?

Yes, substitute granulated sugar or honey; dissolve it fully in the hot water before adding brandy.

Is a Brandy Toddy served hot or cold?

It's served warm, typically in a heat-safe glass or mug.