Picklewich (Jimmy John’s)
This Picklewich recipe is a copycat of the popular, limited edition Jimmy John's menu item. Who needs a roll when you can serve all your sandwich fillings nestled in a large pickle?
🍴Copycat
This Picklewich recipe is a copycat of the popular, limited edition Jimmy John's menu item. Who needs a roll when you can serve all your sandwich fillings nestled in a large pickle?

Check what you already have. We'll leave it off your shopping list.
CookOS may earn a commission from Instacart orders.
Prices vary by store
*Service fees apply. Instacart® and the Instacart logo are registered trademarks of Maplebear Inc. d/b/a Instacart.
Slice the pickle in half, long ways.
Use a spoon to gently scoop out the middle seed portion of the pickle. Don’t scoop too deep as you want to leave some filling for support.
Use a paper towel to dab the pickles to dry them a bit.
Choose the pickle half that will be on the bottom. If it’s not sitting flat, flip it over so the outside of the pickle is facing up and use a knife to trim the bottom so it will sit flat.
Spread the mayo on the inside of the pickle where you scooped out the seeds.
Fold the lunch meat and place it in the hole, with a bit hanging over each side.
Cut the tomato and onion slices in half and add those to the sandwich, starting with the tomato. It will start getting tall at this point, so be careful it doesn’t fall apart on you.
Cut the cheese slice in half and add it to the sandwich before adding the lettuce.
Have the toothpicks ready and add the top of the pickle, lining it up with the other pickle half. Slip a toothpick through the top of each end of the pickle pushing it all the way to the bottom of the sandwich, ending with a toothpick in the middle. This will keep it from falling apart.
Cut in half and enjoy!