An authentic Philly cheesesteak combines thinly shaved ribeye steak with caramelized onions and creamy homemade cheese whiz on a hoagie roll. This recipe delivers the classic Philadelphia sandwich with elevated, made-from-scratch components.
Delivery in as fast as one hour.*
Prices vary by store
*Service fees apply. Instacart® and the Instacart logo are registered trademarks of Maplebear Inc. d/b/a Instacart.
Using a very sharp knife, shave the ribeye steak as thinly as possible. Set aside any fat trimmings.
In a large skillet over medium-high heat, melt the beef tallow. Add the chopped onions and cook until they develop a light char and soften. Remove from the pan and set aside.
In the same or another skillet, add the reserved ribeye fat trimmings and render them down over medium-high heat.
Add the shaved ribeye to the pan with the rendered fat. Spread it into a single layer and allow it to cook and caramelize without overcrowding the pan.
Once the steak is cooked, add the cooked onions back to the skillet.
Using a bench scraper or two spatulas, chop the steak and onions together in the pan until well combined and finely chopped.
Season the steak and onion mixture with salt and pepper to taste.
To make the cheese sauce, gently warm the milk in a small saucepan over low-medium heat. Do not boil.
Add the American cheese slices to the warm milk and stir until they are fully melted and incorporated.
Lower the heat and stir in the shredded sharp cheddar cheese to thicken the sauce.
Add the paprika for color and stir until the cheese sauce is smooth and creamy.
In the skillet, shape the steak and onion mixture into a line roughly the size of your hoagie roll.
Pour a generous amount of the cheese whiz over the steak mixture.
Slice your hoagie roll open and place it face down on top of the meat and cheese in the pan. Allow it to steam for a couple of minutes to soften the bread.
To serve, place a piece of parchment paper (or a plate) over the sandwich and carefully flip the entire pan over. Add more cheese sauce if desired.
Store cooked steak and caramelized onions separately in airtight containers for up to 2 days; reheat gently in a skillet and assemble fresh with warm cheese whiz.
Ribeye is ideal for its marbling and flavor, but sirloin or NY strip can work. Ensure it's thinly sliced or partially frozen before slicing for clean, thin pieces.
Partially freeze the ribeye for 1–2 hours until firm but not solid, then slice against the grain using a sharp knife. A meat slicer also works well.
Homemade cheese whiz made with milk and American cheese is creamier and fresher. Store-bought adds preservatives but is faster; use 1/2 cup as a substitute.
Cook the steak and onions ahead and store separately in the fridge for up to 2 days. Reheat gently in a skillet before assembling with fresh cheese whiz and warm hoagie roll.
Use a soft, sturdy Italian hoagie roll that can hold the filling without falling apart. Lightly toast it for better texture and to prevent sogginess.
Braised Lamb Shanks with Spiced Rice
90 min · The Golden Balance
Spicy Beef Arayes
25 min · The Golden Balance
Buffalo Chicken Dip
45 min · The Golden Balance
Stove Top Stuffing Meatloaf
85 min
Cajun Spaghetti With Creole Meat Sauce
55 min
BBQ Pork Sandwich
35 min
Creamy Corn Chowder
45 min
Honey Butter Corn
15 min
Chunky Chili
490 min
Easy Shrimp Etouffee
Crawfish Etouffee
