Philly Cheesesteak Tour Review
This video taste test compares three iconic Philadelphia cheesesteak spots—Pat's King of Steaks, Geno's Steaks, and Jim's on South—with Pat's winning against Geno's but Jim's earning top honors overall.
MixedCreator recommends$ price range
What the creator ordered
- Pat's Provolone Cheesesteak
- Pat's Cheez Whiz Cheesesteak
- Pat's Cooper American Cheesesteak
- Geno's Cooper Sharp Cheesesteak
- Geno's Cheez Whiz Cheesesteak
- Jim's Cheez Whiz Cheesesteak
Standout moments
- +Jim's on South was the overall winner with an 8.5/10 rating.
- +Pat's King of Steaks was rated a solid 7/10 and preferred over Geno's.
- +The Cheez Whiz at Geno's was noted as being better than at Pat's.
What to know
- −Geno's Steaks was the least favorite, with the meat being a specific point of criticism and earning a 5/10 rating.
Was this review helpful?
Tips & Notes
Pro tips
- Visit all three shops in sequence to taste while sandwiches are fresh—order timing matters for temperature and texture comparison.
- Try the same cheese option across locations (e.g., Provolone at each shop) to isolate differences in meat quality, cooking method, and bread.
- Take notes on meat texture (shredded vs. sliced), cheese melt quality, and bread crispness to identify what makes each location distinct.
Common Questions
Which restaurant won the cheesesteak taste test?
Jim's on South was crowned the favorite overall, though Pat's King of Steaks beat Geno's Steaks in a direct comparison.
What cheese options were tested?
The creators tried different cheese combinations across all three locations to evaluate how each shop prepares their steaks.
Why compare Pat's and Geno's specifically?
Pat's and Geno's are across the street from each other in South Philadelphia and are the most direct rivals in the Philly cheesesteak world.
Is this a professional review or amateur taste test?
This is an amateur taste test by creators @applesauceandadhd and her partner Matthew, offering a casual, personal perspective on the three shops.
