Girl Scout Cookies Taste Test
A first-time Girl Scout cookie tasting that rates eight popular flavors on taste and quality, revealing unexpected favorites like Caramel deLites while confirming dislikes for mint and citrus varieties.
Mixed
What the creator ordered
- Adventurefuls (rated 7/10)
- Caramel deLites (rated 10/10)
- Lemonades (rated 6/10)
- Peanut Butter Patties (rated 9/10)
- Peanut Butter Sandwich (rated 5/10)
- Trefoils (rated 8/10)
- Exploremos - almond-flavored cookie (rated 7/10)
- Thin Mints (rated 6/10)
Standout moments
- +Loved the Caramel deLites (10/10) for their toasted coconut and chewy caramel.
- +Enjoyed the Peanut Butter Patties (9/10) for the classic chocolate and peanut butter combination.
What to know
- −Disliked the lemon and mint flavors in the Lemonades and Thin Mints due to personal preference.
- −Found the texture of the Peanut Butter Sandwich (an oatmeal cookie) to be 'weird'.
- −Thought the Adventurefuls were too crunchy and would have preferred a softer, brownie-like texture.
Was this review helpful?
Tips & Notes
Pro tips
- Taste cookies at room temperature to fully experience each flavor's profile without cold suppressing taste buds.
- Take notes on texture, sweetness level, and aftertaste to identify patterns in flavor preferences.
- Palate cleanse between tastings with water or plain crackers to avoid flavor carry-over bias.
Equipment
video camera or smartphone · rating sheet or scorecard
Common Questions
What Girl Scout cookie flavors are included in this taste test?
The taste test covers eight popular Girl Scout cookie flavors, including Caramel deLites, mint-flavored varieties, and lemon-flavored options.
How are the cookies rated in this video?
Each cookie is rated on a scale of 1 to 10 based on taste, texture, and overall appeal.
What was the highest-rated cookie?
Caramel deLites emerged as a new favorite, earning a high rating for flavor and quality.
Are there any cookies that didn't perform well?
Mint and lemon-flavored cookies received lower ratings, confirming a preference against these flavor profiles.
